13 Songs About Peanut Butter (2023)

Peanut butter, a popular pantry staple, has made a surprising and delightful appearance in music. From pop to blues, this unconventional theme has been utilized as a metaphor, memory, or playful element. 

In this article, we delve into 13 unique songs where peanut butter takes center stage. Prepare to add a tasty twist to your playlist as we explore this intriguing intersection of music and the beloved spread.

13. “Peanut Butter” by The Marathons

“Peanut Butter” by The Marathons is a charming mélange of nostalgia and kitsch. It’s a foot-tapping, head-bobbing time capsule back to the early 60s, filled with doo-wop charm and rhythmic vitality. The lively percussion, the playful, almost cheeky lyrics, and the harmonious backing vocals, all blend together to create a rich, creamy audio feast. This song is a testament to a simpler era, an auditory peanut butter sandwich, familiar and comforting. With its toe-tapping, joy-inducing rhythm and memorable chorus, it has the ability to spread a layer of light-hearted fun on the bread of your day, just like the title suggests.

12. “Peanut Butter Jelly” by Galantis

“Peanut Butter Jelly” by Galantis is a kaleidoscopic concoction of whimsical joy. The Swedes fuse 1970s soul—courtesy of Bettye Swann—with contemporary electronic beats, crafting a track that’s as delightfully sticky as its titular sandwich. Martina Sorbara’s vocals dance through the vibrant soundscape, lending an addictive sweetness. Released in 2015, it radiates a timeless charm, somehow feeling both nostalgic and ahead of its time. Listening to it is like opening a musical lunchbox and finding your favourite childhood treat inside, updated with a sophisticated twist. “Peanut Butter Jelly” is a playful, euphoric electronica morsel, a delectable spread of auditory delight.

11. “Peanut Butter” by RuPaul

“Peanut Butter” by RuPaul is a pulsating anthem, a hypnotic synergy of thumping bass and sassy vocals. Draped in RuPaul’s signature irreverence, the track shimmies into your consciousness, inciting a riot of rhythm in your veins. It’s an unabashed celebration of vivacity, a kaleidoscopic confluence of sass and spunk. The song is a disco ball, showering listeners in shards of audacious beats and tongue-in-cheek lyrics. It’s a joyous romp through the land of unapologetic self-expression, an exhilarating rollercoaster ride that leaves you breathless and craving more. With “Peanut Butter,” RuPaul serves a delectable dollop of audacity on a silver platter of funk.

10. “Peanut Butter Jelly Time” by Buckwheat Boyz

Sonic mischief personified, “Peanut Butter Jelly Time” by Buckwheat Boyz is an infectiously whimsical anthem that thrives on its own absurdity. This daft masterpiece taps into a primal joy, where the nonsensical becomes the norm. Its minimalist approach – a barebones electronic beat paired with a chant-like lyrical progression – is as hypnotic as it is perplexing. Its earworm quality is undeniable, burrowing into your consciousness, converting even the most resistant listener into a helpless participant in its culinary dance. A kitsch celebration of life’s simple pleasures, the song serves an auditory PB&J sandwich – childlike, goofy, yet oddly satisfying.

9. “Mean Mr. Mustard” by The Beatles

“Mean Mr. Mustard” is a quirky gem tucked away in the illustrious Abbey Road album by The Beatles. Penned by the talented John Lennon, it exudes a playful and mischievous vibe that captures the essence of the band’s experimental phase. Inspired by a tale of a stingy character, Lennon weaves a whimsical narrative of a man so desperate to hold onto his wealth that he hides it in peculiar places. Though Lennon himself dismissed it as “a bit of crap,” the song’s infectious melody and clever lyrics make it an endearing addition to the album’s medley. The track seamlessly segues into “Polythene Pam,” showcasing The Beatles’ unmatched ability to create cohesive musical journeys. The original version’s clean ending, preserved in special editions, adds a delightful touch for devoted fans. “Mean Mr. Mustard” is a testament to The Beatles’ boundless creativity and their knack for crafting unforgettable tunes.

8. “Peanut Butter Conspiracy” by Jimmy Buffett

“Peanut Butter Conspiracy” is a whimsical romp, a lyrical joyride courtesy of Jimmy Buffett. The song weaves a tale that’s warm, delightful, and laugh-out-loud funny, the perfect antidote to the humdrum of everyday life. Buffett’s characteristic charm and wit are on full display, his voice, a comforting lullaby. The melody, as playful as a beachside summer breeze, carries the listener through a world of peanut butter dreams, where life’s complexities are reduced to the simple joy of a favorite childhood snack. This song is a tantalizing musical sandwich, spread thick with whimsy and nostalgia, a savory bite of Buffett at his best.

7. “Peanut Butter & Jelly” by Christina Milian

Christina Milian’s “Peanut Butter & Jelly” hits the sweet spot between the sentimental and the fun. Drenched in playful metaphors, this audacious track feels like a nostalgic childhood memory wrapped in a glistening pop package. Milian’s voice, like honey-glazed silk, weaves a tale of uncomplicated love, as comforting as the titular sandwich itself. The beats are infectious, an irresistible dance-invitation, while the lyrics are a delightful blend of silliness and sincerity. With this song, Milian doesn’t just serve a snack, she serves a feast – for the ears, the heart, and the dancing shoes. A true nostalgia-infused bop!

6. “Peanut Butter” by Twennynine featuring Lenny White 

Immersing oneself in “Peanut Butter” by Twennynine with Lenny White is akin to stepping into a vibrant time capsule of funk. With its heady blend of smooth, buttery basslines and electrifying keys, the track captures an era while transcending it. White’s rhythm, akin to a pulsating heartbeat, propels the listener through a cosmos of grooves. The vocal arrangements provide a delightful contrast, a sweetly playful innocence against the song’s robust sound. “Peanut Butter” is an auditory joyride, a delectable fusion of soul, funk, and jazz elements that both satiates and leaves you hungering for more. An exquisitely layered, toe-tapping treat.

5. “Peanut Butter” by The Royal Guardsmen

The Royal Guardsmen’s “Peanut Butter” is a whimsical auditory delight. It’s a jester’s ballad, swaying between the playful and the profound, hidden beneath a veneer of peanut-buttery innocence. The joyful instrumentation frolics like a child in a summer field, while the vocals, warm and nostalgic, spread smoothly over the track like the titular condiment. The lyricism is deceptively simple yet captivating, spinning everyday whimsy into gold. The song evokes a longing for simpler times, while celebrating the mundane. It’s a charming paradox, a lighthearted serenade to childhood nostalgia. In all, “Peanut Butter” is a tasty, addictive slice of auditory comfort food.

4. “Peanut Butter Jelly” by Cadillac Don & J-Money

“Peanut Butter Jelly” by Cadillac Don & J-Money is a unique sonic concoction that’s equally delicious and infectious. The duo’s lyrical prowess is akin to peanut butter and jelly — unexpected, but harmoniously blended. Their southern roots echo in the thumping bass and rhythmic claps, a nostalgic nod to the classic Dirty South era. The hook, catchy and repetitive, sticks to your consciousness like PB&J to the roof of your mouth, creating an earworm that refuses to leave. This track is unapologetically fun, defying traditional genres, a musical sandwich that is equally comfortable at block parties or on road trips. It’s a sticky, sweet, hip-hop treat.

3. “Peanut Butter” by Gwen Guthrie

Gwen Guthrie’s “Peanut Butter” is a delectable auditory treat, smooth and rich as its namesake. Guthrie’s silken voice spreads across the track, melting into a toe-tapping rhythm, creating a classic 80s dance floor delight. The synth-heavy backing track is an invigorating time capsule, invoking neon lights and disco balls. The lyrics, slightly whimsical yet infectiously catchy, marry perfectly with Guthrie’s warm, inviting vocal delivery. It’s a song that sticks to your memory, much like a spoonful of peanut butter to the roof of your mouth – an experience that’s unforgettably satisfying. The ultimate sonic sandwich of joy and nostalgia.

2. “Peanut Butter” by Lisa Loeb

Bathing in the honeyed tones of Lisa Loeb’s “Peanut Butter,” one experiences an audio picnic. The song, a flavorful concoction, spreads smoothly over the bread of pop, with a crunch of acoustic guitars. Loeb’s sugary-sweet vocals are the jelly, perfectly harmonizing with the playful, yet profound, lyrical introspection. The melody is a sticky earworm, sticking to your consciousness like peanut butter to the roof of your mouth. And the whimsical undertones? Pure sprinkles of childhood nostalgia. “Peanut Butter” is an auditory sandwich, a heartwarming blend of comfort and contemplation, proof that Lisa Loeb continues to serve up musical snacks that truly satisfy.

1. “Peanut Butter” by The J Geils Band

“Peanut Butter” by The J Geils Band is a delectable serving of classic rock, spiked with funky blues undertones. It’s an auditory sandwich, the crunchy guitar riffs spreading smoothly like the titular condiment. The rhythmic percussion pulses with an irresistible heartbeat, while the vocals ooze a raw, robust flavor, harmonizing with the taste of nostalgia. You’ll find yourself grooving to its relatable lyrics, a testament to the band’s knack for storytelling. It’s a song that makes your soul dance, the buttery melody sticking to the roof of your mind. “Peanut Butter” is an unforgettable, tantalizing bite of the J Geils Band’s musical feast.